THE WALSH 30-ODD (Rolling Stone 500 rankings in parentheses)
1 R.E.M. 1 Murmur (197) RS also lists Automatic for the People (247)
2 Pretenders 1 Pretenders (155)
3 Nirvana 1 Nevermind (17) RS also lists MTV Unplugged in New York (311), In Utero (439)
4 Blondie 1 Parallel Lines (140)
5 Simon and Garfunkel 1 Bookends (233) RS also lists Bridge Over Troubled Water (51), Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme (201), Greatest Hits 3 (293)
6 Bob Dylan Greatest Hits, Volume 2 2 RS lists Highway 61 Revisited (4), Blonde on Blonde (9), Blood on the Tracks (16), Bringing It All Back Home (31), The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan (97), Desire (174), The Basement Tapes (291), John Wesley Harding (301), Time Out of Mind (408), Love and Theft (467)
7 Smiths 1 The Queen Is Dead (216)/The Smiths (481) RS also lists Meat Is Murder (295), Louder Than Bombs (365)
8 Paul Simon 1 Graceland (81) RS also lists There Goes Rhymin' Simon (267)
9 X Under the Big Black Sun/Los Angeles (286)/Wild Gift (334)
10 Replacements 1 Pleased to Meet Me/Tim (136) RS also lists Let It Be (239)
11 Phantom Limbs 1 Romance
12 Liz Phair 1 Whip-Smart RS lists Exile in Guyville (328)
13 Beatles 1 Rubber Soul (5)/Revolver (3) RS also lists Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band (1), The Beatles (The White Album) (10), Abbey Road (14), Please Please Me (39), Meet the Beatles (59), Let It Be (86), Help (332), A Hard Day's Night (388), With the Beatles (420)
14 Green on Red Gravity Talks
15 Strokes Is This It (367)
16 Lone Justice Lone Justice
17 Frank Sinatra Songs for Swingin' Lovers (306) RS also lists In the Wee Small Hours (100)
18 Blake Babies 1 Sunburn
19 Juliana Hatfield Hey Babe
20 Aztec Camera High Land, Hard Rain
21 Go-Go's Beauty and the Beat (414)
22 Echo and the Bunnymen 1 Crocodiles RS lists Heaven Up Here (471)
23 James Taylor 1 Sweet Baby James (103)
24 Shins Oh, Inverted World
25 Eminem 1 The Marshall Mathers LP (302)/The Slim Shady LP (273) RS also lists The Eminem Show (317)
26 Romeo Void 1 Benefactor
27 Psychedelic Furs 1 Forever Now
28 K.D. Lang 1 Shadowland
29 Neil Diamond Classics: The Early Years/His 12 Greatest Hits RS lists The Neil Diamond Collection (222)
30 Los Lobos How Will the Wolf Survive? (461)
31 Bow Wow Wow 4 I Want Candy
32 Belly Star
33 Let's Active Afoot 5
34 Leonard Cohen The Best of Leonard Cohen
35 Slow Children Slow Children/Mad About Town
36 Gordon Lightfoot 6 Gord's Gold

Notes

This is a purely subjective and somewhat goofy list of the albums that, in my humble opinion, rock. (All right, maybe James Taylor and Neil Diamond and Gordon Lightfoot don't exactly rock, and Frank Sinatra certainly doesn't, but you know what I mean.) I'm not saying, for instance, that the Phantom Limbs were more important or more talented or better in any sense than, for instance, the Beatles; I'm just saying that while the Beatles are important to me, the Limbs are more important to me. The Rolling Stones and the Who and U2 and countless other acts were great but have just never been personal favorites of mine. I feel I owe a specific apology to Elvis Costello, whom I'm hoping to get more acquainted with someday.

Unlike Rolling Stone, I limited myself to one entry per artist, aside from the Simon and Garfunkel/Paul Simon and Blake Babies/Juliana Hatfield overlaps. In cases where I thought designating a single album would be arbitrary and unfair, I listed two or three.

Like Rolling Stone, I'm all over the map on whether to include greatest-hits collections.

Further explanations can be found in the footnotes:

1 Although the listed album(s) was a clear choice, the artist has at least one other album that ranks among my favorites.

2 It's strange, I know, but I didn't get to know Dylan through albums.

3 I definitely got to know Simon and Garfunkel through albums, so I'm staying away from Greatest Hits.

4 An arbitrary choice. Bow Wow Wow songs were repackaged every which way.

5 Some say Afoot was more demo than album. It was certainly more EP than LP. I don't care.

6 It's a sentimental choice, all right?